America’s 10 greatest athletes of all time
· Yahoo Sports
The debate over who belongs on the short list of America’s greatest athletes has raged for decades, across barbershops, sports bars, and broadcast studios. And it should. The United States has produced a staggering volume of transcendent talent: gold medalists, record-breakers, cultural icons, and generational dominators who didn’t just win, they redefined what winning looked like. The conversation spans centuries of sport, from dusty baseball diamonds and boxing rings to swimming pools, gymnastics floors, and gleaming basketball arenas.
Visit catcross.org for more information.
What unites everyone on this list isn’t just greatness. It’s the kind of greatness that stops time. The performances that made entire nations hold their breath. The careers that didn’t just fill trophy cases but shifted the culture of sport itself. Some of these athletes transcended their era; others transcended sport entirely. A few did both.
MORE: Most home runs among active MLB players
These are the athletes who, when the smoke clears and the stats are tallied, stand above everyone else. Ten names. One country. An argument that never gets old.
10. LeBron James
Los Angeles Lakers forward LeBron James (23) during the first half against the Brooklyn Nets at Crypto.com Arena. Credit: William Liang-Imagn Images4 NBA championships (2012, 2013, 2016, 2020) | 4x Finals MVP | 4x NBA MVP | 21x All-Star
LeBron James entered the NBA at 18 as a living prophecy and spent the next two decades making sure he lived up to every word of it. He carried franchises in Cleveland, Miami, and Los Angeles to titles, something no other player in the modern era has done across three different teams. The argument about where he stands in the GOAT conversation hasn’t ended, and the fact that it’s still happening tells you everything about his legacy.
9. Jesse Owens
4 Olympic gold medals: 100m, 200m, long jump, 4x100m relay (Berlin, 1936)
At the 1936 Berlin Olympics, Jesse Owens did something that went far beyond sport. In front of Adolf Hitler and a crowd primed to celebrate Aryan supremacy, Owens, a Black American from Alabama, won four gold medals in track and field and became the most decorated athlete at those Games. ESPN credited him with “single-handedly crushing Hitler’s myth of Aryan supremacy,” which might be the most extraordinary sentence ever written about a sporting performance.
8. Serena Williams
23 Grand Slam singles titles | 4 Olympic gold medals | Career Golden Slam
Serena Williams didn’t just dominate women’s tennis. She reset the standard for what dominance could look like. Her 23 Grand Slam singles titles are an Open Era record, achieved over nearly two decades during which she consistently returned stronger after injuries, childbirth, and health scares. She is, simply put, the greatest female tennis player who ever lived and one of the greatest athletes, full stop.
7. Jim Thorpe
Olympic gold in pentathlon and decathlon (Stockholm, 1912) | NFL | MLB
Jim Thorpe was the original multi-sport phenomenon, and no one has quite matched him since. He swept the pentathlon and decathlon at the 1912 Stockholm Olympics, events that test the full range of human athleticism, then went on to play professional baseball and 12 seasons of professional football. He was also the first president of the organization that would become the NFL, making him one of the most consequential figures in all of American sports history.
6. Tiger Woods
15 major championships | 82 PGA Tour wins (tied all-time record)
Tiger Woods didn’t just dominate golf. He made an entire generation care about golf for the first time. His 15 major championships are second only to Jack Nicklaus’s 18, and his 82 PGA Tour victories tie Sam Snead’s all-time record. What separates Woods, though, is the magnitude of his comebacks, including the 2019 Masters win after multiple back surgeries that had most observers assuming his career was finished.
5. Simone Biles
Jul 28, 2024; Paris, France; Simone Biles of the United States performs on the uneven bars in womenís qualification during the Paris 2024 Olympic Summer Games at Bercy Arena. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports | Kyle Terada-USA TODAY SportsRecord 9 U.S. national all-around championships | Most decorated gymnast in Olympic and World Championship history
Simone Biles operates at a level of difficulty that the gymnastics rulebook has literally struggled to keep up with. She has surpassed Vitaly Scherbo as the most successful gymnast of all time across the Olympics and World Championships combined, and her name is attached to multiple skills deemed too dangerous for anyone else to attempt regularly. When she returned from a mental health pause at the 2024 Paris Olympics and won gold, it wasn’t a comeback story. It was a reminder that she never actually left.
4. Michael Phelps
28 Olympic medals (23 gold) | Most decorated Olympian in history | 8 gold medals at a single Games (Beijing, 2008)
Michael Phelps is the most decorated Olympian in history, and it isn’t particularly close. His 23 gold medals are more than double the count of his nearest rivals, and his eight-gold performance in Beijing in 2008 remains one of the most astonishing single-Games achievements in Olympic history. Five Olympics, five decades, and the record books still haven’t recovered.
SEE ALSO: Greatest NFL MVP seasons ever, ranked from elite to legendary
3. Babe Ruth
714 career home runs | .342 career batting average | 7x World Series champion
Babe Ruth played baseball in an era before night games, free agency, or modern conditioning, and still put up numbers that left the sport speechless for a century. Between 1926 and 1932 alone, he averaged 49 home runs per season with a .353 batting average. Ruth didn’t just reshape the game’s statistics; he reshaped its identity, turning the home run into the sport’s defining currency.
2. Muhammad Ali
56 wins (37 KOs) | 3x heavyweight world champion | Olympic gold, 1960
Muhammad Ali was a heavyweight champion who existed in a category entirely of his own making. His record of 56 wins and 37 knockouts doesn’t begin to capture what he meant to sport, to America, and to the world. He surrendered the peak years of his career rather than compromise his principles, then came back to reclaim the title anyway. The man called himself The Greatest before he proved it, and then he proved it anyway.
1. Michael Jordan
6 NBA championships | 6x Finals MVP | 5x MVP | 10 scoring titles | 30.1 PPG career average
There is no credible argument against Michael Jordan holding this position. Six titles, six Finals MVPs, never losing an NBA Finals series: Jordan’s résumé is airtight in a way that defies revisionism. He won 10 scoring titles, retired with the highest career scoring average in NBA history at 30.1 points per game, and simultaneously built one of the most recognizable global sports brands in history. The floor and the ceiling of this list both belong to him.
The GOAT debate will never die, and that’s the point
Sports would be a lesser thing if we ever settled this argument once and for all. Every name on this list carries a case, a legacy, and a fanbase willing to go to the mat for them. From Jesse Owens defying history in Berlin to Michael Jordan making basketball a religion, America’s greatest athletes didn’t just play their sport; they made it a religion. They played it in a way that made the rest of the world stop and watch. The debate lives on because the greatness does too.